David Caprio Deserves Progressives' Support

Posted by: David Segal in Democrats

UPDATE: I want to be clear that this post is about State Representative David Caprio.  I'm not supporting anybody in the gubernatorial race.  I also forgot to mention several more key initiatives on which David's voted with the left in the last couple of years, including raising the gas tax to fund RIPTA, taxing capital gains as income, and supporting a contentious measure to put an open space bond on last year's ballot.  I added this line to the follow-up post, but this one will probably be read by more people: Put simply, if everybody voted with us as much as David has, we'd win almost every battle.

ORIGINAL: Election season is upon us, and I'm supporting my colleague State Rep David Caprio.  His political philosophy has evolved during his decade in office: He's moved steadily left over the years, and that's precisely the sort of thing we ought to take notice of and actively encourage, in him and in other elected officials.  We don't do that by ganging up on him because he's imperfect -- Especially when, in fact, he's been quite good on a slew of issues that are very important to progressives.

Some examples, culled during my 3 years as his colleague:

-Gay marriage co-sponsor, and supporter of the various other gay rights initiatives we've pushed, including monitoring of hate crimes against those who identify as transgender, funeral rights, etc;
-Pro-choice;
-Supports net-metering, wind-farm development, and renewable energy tax credits;
-Has supported three or four public-transit initiatives -- becoming an active advocate for the UPass program, after initially opposing out of concern that it'd raise tuition costs.  He met with the Sierra Club, and changed his position;
-Pro medical marijuana, and decriminalization;
-Pro probation reform (and an active advocate for it) and for ending mandatory minimum sentences, and easy expungement for first-time offenders;
-Supports pre-registration, National Popular Vote, and elections to fill US Senate vacancies;
-Voted to ban utility shut-offs for families with small children;
-Supported the foreclosure mediation bill that we just overrode the veto of;
-Voted to raise the capital gains tax to fund education -- the key budget amendment vote from a couple of years ago.

And, most critically from my perspective, in 2008 we were desperately scrambling for every vote we could muster against the draconian E-Verify legislation.  There was a lot of pressure on each and every one of us to vote the other way -- plenty of nasty phone calls and emails, active organizing by RISC, RIILE, and a number of other groups.  It was an uphill fight, and we knew we were going to lose, but every "No" vote was a courageous signal to the reactionaries, and a key building block for future work -- and David was one of just 17 neas in a chamber dominated by Democrats.  I pledged to him in that moment that I would make sure that all progressives knew that he'd stood with us, and remind the left of how terrible the anti-immigrant climate was over the course of that session -- and that I'd support him come election time.  And I stand by that promise. 

The following year he lobbied our colleagues, including many whom the left doesn't traditionally have access to, to oppose the measure, and helped secure several votes against it.  We came within a hair of killing the thing on the floor.  (And in the gallery, our supporters -- who'd technically lost the vote -- cheered more loudly than the bill's backers.)

And he's a supporter of Gordon Fox for the speakership.

In my time in the legislature, David's never advocated a reactionary agenda -- He's never been a gay-bater, or anti-immigrant, or pushed a regressive tax agenda, never ever been somebody we've had to fight against.  Where he's not been with us at the start, he's willingly engaged in conversation, and frequently changed his stance and supported a cause once he's been convinced of its merits.  

And that's all we can ask.  None of us is perfect, and perfection's far too strong a standard to hold people to -- nor is it a progressive one.  Progressives understand that everybody develops in the context of the environment from which they came.  Not everybody's born a liberal -- I was raised in a relatively conservative household, with Rush Limbaugh frequently droning out of the car radio on the way to and from school.  But I moved left over the years through a combination of personal experiences and active tutelage by friends whom I trusted and respected.  We can encourage that sort of change in people, even elected officials, by engaging them in good faith -- by making sure that they know that if they go out on the limb for us, we'll be there to back them up.

The movement needs to support those who engage us earnestly, and will be with us on most of the important issues: We can't ask a Rep or Senator to support us on this or that item, have him or her oblige, go and screw 'em anyway because he or she was only with us 80% of the time, and then still expect anybody else in the building to give a heck what we have to say.  How can we ever convert the bulk of the membership -- those who, say, support us 50% of the time -- into people who will support us 60% or 70% or 80% of the time, if we're working against the 80% supporters?  


David deserves our support, and our encouragement, and should generally be understood as a willing partner as we strive to develop a progressive Rhode Island, and a healthier economy based on our state's wonderful and unique assets.

 

Tagged in: David Caprio
Comments (18)Add Comment
rasputinkhlyst
And Caprio wants to wack the State Employees Pensions more too.
written by rasputinkhlyst, January 21, 2010
RI State Employess already pay the highest in the country for a marginal payback.

Caprio supports the alternative flat tax.

Caprio is viewed favorably by Anchor Rising, last time I looked (Which admittedly was a long time ago.

His analogy about the number of citizens sitting at the convention center paying 60% of the tax for the state may be numerically true; but those same folks OWN 90% of the wealth.

Let me know when he changes on THESE issues and he may have earned a vote. I suspect many of the other issues are not going anywhere soon.

When he supports the MIDDLE CLASS more, perhaps I will give him a closer look.
Ali LaPointe
didn't his brother .....
written by Ali LaPointe, January 21, 2010
say that he is joining the State wide coalition to run candidates against progressives? If I were an Assembly memebr I would think Caprio is out to get me, not support me
andrewgilmartin
More interested in Smith Hill than Peace Dale flats
written by andrewgilmartin, January 21, 2010
To "engage us earnestly" is much less than I expect from my legislative representative. David Caprio is the least engaged in the community. Dismissive is a better fit.

In 2009 I attended two public budget informational meetings with David Caprio and other legislators from South Kingstown & Narragansett. At both of these meeting Caprio refused to answer specific questions about his priorities and even his broad stance on issues. When pressed, his response was paternalistic about the "complexity" of the budget and the issues. These meetings where well attended by people who were (1) his constituents and (2) clearly understood the complexity of both the budget situation and the legislative processes. Frankly, this is insulting.

Apart from these meetings I have yet to see David Caprio attend any other community meetings here in South Kingstown and/or Narragansett. The evidence, my experience, and even the content of your posting is of a legislator clearly more interested in what happens on Smith hill than what happens in the Peace Dale flats.
SouthCountyKing
"election season is upon us..."
written by SouthCountyKing, January 21, 2010
Really? Last time I checked it was January, and we've got a Providence Rep up here throwing a pep rally for a South County legislator (and a Caprio at that?). Either Segal is in with the Lynch campaign, or Representative Caprio is terrified of his career coming to an inglorious stop this fall.

From what I can tell, Progressives understand authentic values and a fighting spirit. I look at David [Caprio], and I see someone who doesn't particularly care where his vote falls, is looking to win the Smith Hill popularity contest, and will never move our issues forward. Support that kind of spinelessness at your own peril.
soccermomsue
no, it's certainly not perfecton..
written by soccermomsue, January 21, 2010
So now we are supposed to feel sorry for the Caprios for the horrible circumstances they were raised in? The wealth and privilege they had to overcome? poor things!

great that the inside baseball is alive and well.

I groaned out loud when I read in last weeks South County Independent that Rep. David Caprio will be "focused like a laser bean on addressing the serious financial issues facing the state" while the only actual bill he aludes to intendes to "make it easier for members of the Historic Cemeteries Commission to access graveyards on private property."

With laser beams like that, who needs progress?
-Sue
soccermomsue
article link
written by soccermomsue, January 21, 2010
if you want to know what the other south county lawmakers are talking about - municipal aid, overdraft fees and school funding:

http://www.scindependent.com/articles/2010/01/15/local/doc4b4f59d2c3437908625280.txt
melody
...
written by melody, January 21, 2010
I continue to be surprised that anyone has the patience to spend years to "bring along" an elected representative to do the right thing in support of progressive values. Waiting for someone (Caprio) to be convinced he should support progressive positions is a tired argument. No more making excuses. We don't have any more time with health care, unemployment, and quality education hanging in the balance. If Mr. Caprio wanted to be the progressive in this race he should have thought about that a long time ago.

Teresa Tanzi is the progressive candidate and - we don't need to "bring her along." Elect a leader, a true progressive.
IHeartWellstone
Ganging Up? Really...
written by IHeartWellstone, January 21, 2010
For full disclosure I enthusiastically support Teresa Tanzi whose name was not even mentioned in the editorial. I don't think Caprio is a bad guy and his voting record is not terrible although he has had several opportunities to oppose the flat tax and he has not. I take real issue with the insinuation that progressives like me and some of my friends are "ganging up" on him because he is imperfect and wish the author had not used the phrase. I does not understand the energy and enthusiasm that Teresa is generating. My support of Teresa has everything to do with who she is and her values. She is active locally in South County on a host of good causes and groups from the Johnny Cake Center to the local sustainable growth and green groups. Teresa is a champion at the statewide level to on issues of social justice and equality. Every decision she makes on Smith Hill be viewed through the prism of how will this affect my family and my community? While Caprio votes for some progressive things here and there, he not a Progressive. Teresa is a champion and supports my values. I know many of her supporters and they are inspired by her candidacy and it has nothing to do with 'ganging up' on David Caprio. We support her campaign for the same reason many of us support David Segal, she embodies what we think an elected official should be. I wish the author had chosen his words differently.
Brian Hull
With all due respect...
written by Brian Hull, January 21, 2010
http://www.rifuture.org/myblog...eware.html

Caprio is playing you David. The conservative DINO block is positioning themselves to find cover while systematically trying to kneecap their Progressive opponents.
Libby Kimzey
Dear Representative Segal,
written by libbyk, January 21, 2010
I have a lot of respect for the hours of conversation you've had with your less progressive colleagues on these tough issues that matter most. As a former constituent, I thank you for your tireless work.

I look forward to the day when the House and Senate chambers are filled with champions like you - those who have thoughtfully articulated progressive values, who are on the ground in the community, active on the state level, and who can develop common goals and legislation that gets us there alongside colleagues of different backgrounds.

In working towards that vision, and the bettered economy and social fabric that Rhode Island stands to gain, I have no hesitation in supporting Teresa Tanzi for District 34. I hope those who agree with me would put their money where their mouth is, at http://www.teresatanzi.com
Libby Kimzey
That's the last time I end a sentence with a link...
written by libbyk, January 21, 2010
cmark
...
written by cmark, January 21, 2010
Caprio pro-choice? Really? In however many years he sat on the judiciary, I never once heard him say a word for or against. Admittedly, I was not always present, but for someone who wants to claim he is prochoice, where is his record? I'm not aware of any endorsements from Planned Parenthood or NOW or 2:1. Closeted and comfortable is not enough, we need a leader who will help move issues. Teresa Tanzi is not only in alignment with so many of the progressive issues I hold near and dear, she's willing to stick her neck out and be a leader. And that's what we need in the State House.
Matt Jerzyk
I respect Rep. Segal
written by Matt Jerzyk, January 21, 2010

I respect Rep. Segal alot and I agree that Rep. Caprio has been moving to the left. It is plausible that this movement to the left has been a result of Caprio getting primaried in 2008 and now in 2010. Either way, I am interested to see how the Tanzi / Caprio race takes shape.
forsanri
Why Rep. Segal needs Rep. Tanzi
written by forsanri, January 21, 2010
David Segal, Have I got a deal for you!
Let me start by saying this thoughtful post underscores your political skills at harvesting Caprio votes for the progressive cause. While I appreciate your humility to show favor to David Caprio for "coming around," let's just put it out there: You did the hard work in soliciting his vote, and that's why Caprio came around. Keep up the good work!

As a South County resident, I can ask for a lot more though--I want someone who doesn't have to be convinced that our cause is right. Rather than having you spend your valuable time bringing along Rep. Caprio, I think you need an ally, who is there shoulder to shoulder with you, buttressing your arguments, and corraling more votes for the Progressive cause.

I am not alone.

Several other South County residents want to see someone new move up and fight this fight with you--not against you--and that ally is Teresa Tanzi.

She is one of us.

When we send Rep Tanzi to the State House, you won't have to ask for her support; she will already be alongside you asking for other supporters. That is what this progressive movement needs: LEADERS who don't have to be told what the right answer is.

Most South County residents are more than a little concerned that Rep. Caprio's temporary tilt to the left will abruptly cease when Frank moves further and further to the right in his gubernatorial bid (to wit this blog's post that Caprio threw unions under the bus). Considering that David Caprio still lives at home with his parents, it is even easier to see how he might be influenced to vote "for the good of the family" instead of "the good of South County."

Perhaps you can keep convincing Caprio to come around each time, but your efforts would be multiplied with Teresa Tanzi's help in next year's Assembly. We're going to help you out in that regard, so hang in there. Reinforcements are on the way from South County.
sarah007
Not very democratic...
written by sarah007, January 21, 2010
Rep Segal - I think you are forgetting how democracy should work. Elections are not an opportunity to re-elect someone who is "not bad". Elections are an opportunity to elect the best person to represent a district. Tanzi is running a fair campaign, focusing on issues. She is a constituent who feels that Caprio does not represent her, her friends or her neighbors. Shouldn't the district have a choice? I am disappointed that you would want to shut people out of the democratic process. I can't see any reason why Caprio deserves anything. He was elected to make hard decisions. I personally am not impressed with your list of his accomplishments.
progress4ri
The important thing is
written by progress4ri, January 21, 2010
that David Caprio has been on the wrong side of the most important issue of his time in the State House. He has supported the failed trickle-down economics of the flat tax arm-in-arm with Carcieri and leadership, which is the main reason that RI is in an even greater economic mess than most states.

In case we needed any more proof that tax cuts for the rich doesn't work, just look at RI and the flat tax.
Craig OConnor
Give Rep. Segal a break...
written by Craig OConnor, January 23, 2010
I understand where David is coming from. On a day-to-day basis he has to work with people up at the state house, and when they come through for him, it is admirable that he will come through for them. I give David a lot of credit for being so upfront about this, and think his decision is a fine one that makes sense. I strongly support Teresa Tanzi, but in no way does David's decision to support Rep. Caprio disappoint me or make me think less of him. He is doing the hard work at the State House of building relationships and moving people in the right direction, and I respect him for that, and trust he is making the right decision for the situation he is in, and for standing by someone who has stood with him. I know little about Rep. Caprio, and if he does support the flat tax, well that makes me want Teresa to win the seat even more, but I will also continue to support Rep. Segal in any way I can.
LauraC
...
written by LauraC, January 28, 2010
Teresa Tanzi is the candidate who will work to "develop a progressive Rhode Island and a healthier economy". We need a leader who will take a true progressive stand on issues and she is that person. I will continue to support her in any way I can.

Write comment
You must be logged in to post a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy